Obviously a completely integrated package from one developer means that the part, the tool, the drawings and the machining are all linked, all of the time, so changes and improvements are handled with ease. To fully understand the benefits of a complete one-package solution we need to see what happens when we explore the alternative: to use a number of separate packages from different developers and try to get them to work seamlessly together.
Whenever two or more software packages need to communicate there is always room for error. Sometimes it may be a minor problem, but often the problem will be more severe. Each software supplier writes their own code to handle complex geometry. If there are any differences in the way one or the other describes a lofted surface for example, it means you will not get exactly the same shape as was intended. With an integrated product, with both CAD and CAM, there is absolutely no possibility of transfer errors.
2. Data Loss
In some integrated CAD/CAM packages you may add numerous forms of additional information onto your part models—including tolerances, surface finish requirements, machining methods, etc. All of this information can be automatically read by the integrated CAM. However, when transferring model data between two separate products this information is lost.
|Powerful functionalities for the design of complex molds.
||A direct interface.
||A completely integrated solution for the design and machining of molds.
3. Version Lag
This is a very common problem and it happens when one of your software suppliers releases a new version of its software, meaning your other package is now incompatible and will no longer work. You cannot afford to lose half of your capability so you simply have to put the new version back on the shelf until the second supplier catches up.
4. Fragmented Support
As long as you have two or more suppliers then each of them are free to play the blame game when something goes wrong. Is it a CAD problem or a CAM problem? Another aspect of this problem is what happens when you find a bug in the software. If it’s a bug that impacts both packages, you have twice the workload in reporting and monitoring the result.
5. Future Direction
No control. As each software company develops its products, they do so to suit their own goals and requirements. Ultimately this could affect the level of compatibility with other systems.